Early years settings have long relied on circle time as a staple practice for group interaction and learning. However, in today’s evolving educational landscape, there is a growing realisation that circle time may no longer be the most effective approach. In this blog, we will explore why circle time is considered outdated in early years settings and why embracing alternative methods that better support children’s individual needs and development is crucial.

 

1. Lack of Individualised Attention

 

 

 

Circle time often fails to provide the individualised attention that children require. With the entire group gathered together, it becomes challenging for teachers to address each child’s unique interests, abilities, and learning styles. Young children thrive when they receive individual guidance and support tailored to their specific needs. By moving away from the one-size-fits-all approach of circle time, early years settings can better accommodate the diverse learning requirements of each child.

 

 

 

2. Passive Participation

 

 
During circle time, children are typically expected to sit quietly and passively listen to the teacher or take turns speaking. This passive role can lead to disengagement, reduced motivation, and missed opportunities for active learning. Early childhood is a critical period for hands-on exploration and learning through play. By transitioning away from circle time, educators can create more interactive and dynamic learning experiences that encourage children to engage with their environment and participate in their learning actively. Why are you taking them away from their play?
 

 

3. Limited Social Interaction

 

 

 

While circle time aims to foster social interaction, the format often restricts meaningful peer-to-peer communication. The focus tends to be on the practitioner’s instructions or questions, leaving little time for children to interact with each other and develop vital social skills such as collaboration, negotiation, and conflict resolution. By incorporating alternative methods, such as small group activities, early years settings can provide ample opportunities for children to engage in meaningful social interactions, fostering their communication and interpersonal skills.

 

 

 

4. Inflexibility and Lack of Choice

 

 

Circle time follows a predetermined routine or set of activities, leaving little room for flexibility and choice. This rigid structure limits children’s autonomy and inhibits their ability to make decisions about their learning experiences. Early years settings today recognise the importance of child-led learning, where children have the freedom to explore their own interests and shape their learning journey. By embracing more flexible approaches, educators can encourage children to take an active role in their learning, fostering independence and a sense of ownership over their education.

 
5. Cultural and Individual Differences
 

 

Circle time may only sometimes be culturally responsive or inclusive of children from diverse backgrounds. The activities and topics discussed may only resonate with some children’s cultural experiences or interests. Early years settings should strive to create inclusive environments that celebrate and respect all children’s diverse identities, languages, and backgrounds. Educators can ensure that every child’s voice is heard and valued within the learning environment by adopting alternative approaches that are more sensitive to individual and cultural differences.

 

 

As we embrace the evolving landscape of early years education, it’s important to critically examine traditional practices such as circle time. By recognising its limitations, we can move towards more child-centred approaches that prioritise individualised attention, active participation, and meaningful social interaction. Early years settings have a unique opportunity to create inclusive and engaging learning environments that empower every child to thrive.